Neuropsychological Basis of Biases

What is it?  Does it look like a dog to you?  That's what it looks like to most people.  There is a neurological basis for the ability to recognize what this is a picture of, in spite of its incompleteness.  That ability is called "Pattern Recognition."  We are able to recognize patterns when we see them. 

Humans are not the only creatures able to do this.  Chickens can recognize the shadow of a hawk and will flee it when they see it.

We appear to be born with this ability.  Infants can recognize the pattern of the human face and will become agitated when shown a picture of a face with the facial features in the wrong place.

This thing called Pattern Recognition - This is a large topic, one that has been investigated for years by cognitive and neuropsychologists.  We don't plan to go into details about the various aspects and explanations of pattern recognition.  Our intent is to show how it forms the basis of things like biases and even prejudices.

Let's start with a definition: Pattern Recognition is how we recognize, identify, and categorize information, it includes the identification of a complex arrangement of sensory stimuli.  The picture of the dog above is a prime example.  It has a complex arrangement of black shapes which the brain organizes into a cognitive pattern, in this case a "dog."  This is what enable us to categorize and recognize all kinds of things.  Sometimes the pattern presented is ambiguous, and we can see more than one thing, as in this picture:

Is it a vase, or two people facing each other?  Most of us can see both but not simultaneously.

Spatial  Patterns: The pictures we've shown so far are visual patterns.  They do not change over time. 

Temporal Patterns: These are patterns that take place over time.  They involve repeating series of events that occur over time and that by their very repetition become recognizable patterns.  These patterns from the basis of our concept of causality.

Pattern Recognition and Cognitive Categories: It is on the basis of pattern recognition that we form cognitive categories (in linguistics, these are generally what we call "nouns," which are persons, places or things).  Categories are essential for understanding and navigating in the world.

Stereotype: A stereotype is something used to characterize, or describe a category.  Sometimes it is seen as a template, like a prototype, or archetype.  They can be either positive, or negative, or somewhere in between.

Labeling: This involves describing someone or something in a word or short phrase.  All nouns are labels of a sort, a name that is given to a person, place, or thing.  Labeling is an outgrowth of this sort of pattern recognition.  An example is "dog" for the upper left image above.  Another could be describing someone who has broken a law as a "criminal."  Another would be calling someone who has some sort of physical incapacity a "cripple."  The problem that can arise involves the fact that, in addition to denotations, such labels can have connotations, which can be either positive, or negative, or in some cases some of both.

Using labels (and stereotypes) can help simplify the patterns folks recognize.  Neither are automatically detrimental.

The problem arises when it results in over-simplification (i.e., reification) of things that are more complex and/or nuanced.  Unfortunately, there are those who rely on stereotyping and labeling as a way to avoid complexity and/or avoid recognizing their inability to deal with complexity.

Prejudice: The thing about a prejudice is that it involves evaluation (judging something) in advance.  It can and often is based on a stereotype, or label (often contained in the connotation).  It can be either positive, or negative, and in some cases a little of both.

Preference: When looking at bias, it is important to factor in the evaluative portion.  Thus, when looking at a pattern being recognizes, is there a positive, or negative value attached (like a connation attached to the definition of a word). 

When it comes to the flavor or ice cream, some prefer vanilla, while some prefer chocolate.  This can be viewed as a bias in favor of one versus the other.  Similarly, people may prefer not to see certain things, or engage in certain activities.

Cognitive categories Positive, or Negative? These cognitive categories (e.g., stereotypes and prejudices) are not inherently positive, or negative.  There can be positive ones and negative ones (e.g., "war veterans" can be seen positively, while "welfare recipient" can often be seen negatively).

Biases and Pattern Recognition: From this perspective, a bias is simply a pattern (either spatial, or temporal) that we use at times when they (one, or the other, or both) aren't applicable.  They are erroneous patterns that we see that prevent use from actually perceiving reality. 

As with cognitive categories discussed above, they can be either positive, or negative, but what is most important about them is their potential to obscure our perceptions of reality.  This can be especially prevalent in the case of a bias based on a negative stereotype.

So, for example, a person who tends to have a spatial bias for the perception of dirt might see the picture of the dog at the top of this page as actually just a bunch of dirt blotches.  Biases and prejudices can prevent us from seeing reality and they can lead us into a variety of logical fallacies.

Inkblot Test: By the way, it is this ability to recognize patterns, even when the visual material is quite vague, that form the basis of the inkblot test.  So, what do you see?  The "biases" revealed when people state what they see in the inkblot gives some information that can be used to assess personality.

Biases Positive, or Negative?  As with cognitive categories discussed above, they can be either positive, or negative, but what is most important about them is their potential to obscure our perceptions of reality.  This can be especially prevalent in the case of a bias based on a negative stereotype.

 To go to the brief introduction to biases 

 To go to our Logical Fallacies Page 

 To go to Science Page

 To go to the Articles Page

 

All written text on this website copyright © Reality Check Online